“A Valiant Charge”: A Review of The Call of the Bugle by John Amos
(Imagination Press, 2026). ISBN: 979-8-950191-01-5
Readers of my reviews—and the myriad works I’ve created for
the page, stage, and as immersive experiences—know that I have a special place
in my heart for historical fiction. In my book and on my podcast, Every Day
Is a Story All Its Own—are sections and episodes dedicated to Based on a
True Story and finding the gaps in the historical record where an author has
the opportunity to imprint their invented characters, circumstances, and
insights on even the most well-traveled historical gems, such as the fabled
Charge of the Light Brigade (Balaclava in the Crimea, 1854).
While war in general is romantic to many who haven’t
experienced it—a fallacy that a portion of historical fiction writers have aligned
with historians and memoirists to remedy—the cavalry (or infantry) charge
occupies a glorified place of honor. Along with the subject of Tennyson’s oft
recited “The Charge of the Light Brigade,” there’s Prickett’s Charge
(Gettysburg, ~11 years later); the assault on Fort Wagner, led by another unit
as fabled as “the six hundred” cavalrymen of the Seventeenth Lancers et al.,
the 54th Massachusetts; and the 9th Lancers and 4th Dragoon Guards at the
Charge of Audregnies (1917), immortalized (and mythologized) in Steven Spielberg’s
War Horse.
Given my love of historical fiction, familiarity with the
Charge of the Light Brigade through Tennyson’s poem; mainstream historical
nonfiction; the 1936 Michael Curtiz–directed, Max Steiner–scored mythological
epic starring Errol Flynn, Olivia de Havilland, and Patric Knowles; and even
George MacDonald Fraser’s absurdist Flashman at the Charge, I was
motivated to read John Amos’s The Call of the Bugle, and it didn’t
disappoint. In this assessment, I’m far from alone.
The book’s front matter includes 23 review blurbs from
readers, magazine editors, authors, podcast hosts, and even someone from the
Office of the Order of the British Empire (OBE). Full transparency: with all
mass market books and with many books I review, the first thing I do is tear
these pages out. In this case, I didn’t, although I refrained from reading them
until I formulated my own assessment. If you’d like further assessments beyond
the current review, you’ll have plenty from which to choose.
The Call of the Bugle takes as its two lead
characters a journalist who finds a fraught fame through his gift for war
correspondence and a retired general formally of the 17th Lancers who returns
to active duty for the Siege of Sebastopol, which culminates in The Charge. The
journalist is a brilliant device for delivering information from numerous
sources in historical fiction. There’s the journalist’s own point of view;
interviews (in this case) with fellow military men, household staff, and family
members; and the general’s own papers, including extensive diaries. I’ve used a
journalist to great effect in two of my historical fiction novels. The
journalist and general are both figments of the author’s fertile and
research-girded imagination, although I know enough about the time period and
these occupations to know they are skillfully crafted, authentic amalgamations
of many real-life individuals.
At the heart of much historical fiction (especially through algorithm-driven,
box-checking Hollywood formulae) is a love story, and both of The Call
of the Bugle’s central characters have ladies who wait, worry, and
sacrifice for their driven, duty- and answer-bound lovers as they engage in/cover
endless campaigns around the world (there’s never a shortage of work for men
like them). I recently visited my in-laws’ graves at the National Cemetery in
Fort Smith, Arkansas, and inscribed on my mother-in-law’s headstone is “She
also served.” A fair enough point through the lens of The Call of the Bugle.
Same goes for children of military personnel.
As with any genre writing, there are specific litmus tests
for historical fiction. The first is a demonstration of deep research into the historical.
Amos clearly did his research (political, cultural, social) and understands the
two professions about which he writes. When it comes to the fiction
aspect, the mission is to not let the massive amounts of research bog the
narrative down. There must be a balance, a sense of steady, mounting Pace and
Inevitability, while still providing the richness of character and situation
and mystery boxes required by fiction (although the very best historians also employ
these elements). Amos was wise to create these fictional characters. Like Titanic
or Pearl Harbor, we know the macro story, but we can’t know the micro
because the writer invented it. The intertwining and alchemical reactions
produced by the dance of macro and micro provide a third litmus test. I cared
deeply about the journalist and general. The forces arrayed against them in the
geopolitical, ego-driven, high-stakes world they inhabit are considerable (as
they must be in historical fiction) and their weakest moments imprint
effortlessly on our own. As the journalist chases answers—not merely for the
sake of column size and sustained notoriety, but to ultimately save his own
soul through illumination of the general’s—he might as well be a sailor lost at
sea in some maritime epic, as we think… If only there were a lighthouse, a
hunk of sea debris, a passing craft…
As the chapters and story unfold, Amos makes ever-larger use
of the general’s diaries, giving him an opportunity to tell two stories in
parallel, with two distinct voices. We also experience numerous points of view
of a single event through the journalist’s research, interviews, and engagement
with the diaries. This is highly efficient, multilevel storytelling. The quiet
moments before bed are as equally weighty as the sights and sounds of war.
Another aspect of The Call of the Bugle I found
compelling was that it’s a multi-level ghost story. If experiencers and
scholars of war understand anything, it’s that it’s haunting. Growing up
with a father who has PTSD from his intelligence work during the Vietnam War (a
situation mirrored by my recently deceased father-in-law), haunting is
as apt a word as any. Are the hauntings
associated with war throughout the ages purely metaphorical? Literal? Imagined?
For instance, there are myriad accounts of phantom armies appearing on
momentarily mist-shrouded battlefields going back to Antiquity. Are these
Metaphorical? Literal? Imagined? In The Call of the Bugle, it’s some of
each. Accompanying these hauntings is often the call of the bugle.
Whether one rides toward, ignores, or retreats from that sound, and the
consequences of each, is the substance of this well-rendered historical novel,
which I promise will stay with you long after the final page is turned.

Comments